Surfrider Foundation NYC
Homepage
About us
Programs
· Beach clean ups
· Beachscape
· Respect the Beach
Chapter news
Events
Membership
Photos
Resources
Sponsors



Surfrider Foundation

Programs - Beachscape - Long Beach

  The Corps and its plan for Long Beach

A recent ACOE project in East Rockaway, NY.
It has been the NYC Chapter's contention as well as a number of scientific sources that this project poses a significant threat to the future recreational use of the area for surfers, fisherman and beach enthusiasts alike. For the last couple of years NYC Chapter members have actively advocated the ACOE and the City of Long Beach for a more environmental and responsible coastal management plan. As a result of this hard work, there was a very large victory for the Foundation when the Council went back to the ACOE and asked for a different plan. Thus far some considerations may be made by the ACOE to summarize and address the interests of local interests in this area but, overall, the project IS STILL A THREAT.

At this time, the future of this plan depends on public engagement. Currently the ACOE is back in the drawing room trying to work out a new plan and keeps postponing the release date of the Plan. It is imperative that all of those concerned with this project become educated and engaged in this process. The beauty of our beach depends on it. If you use and love this beach review the information attachment "RECENT LETTER FOR CITY COUNCIL" to educate yourself Surfrider's position as well as the previous plan. Print out the attached flyer for posting around the City.

Contact us to attend the next LB Committee meeting, contact a local official, or attend a NYC Chapter meeting to find out how you can help SAVE THE BEACH.

  Previous Plan Facts
What does this plan consist of?
The plan proposed by the Army Corps of Engineers (ACOE) includes the construction of a 110 foot wide berm, at an elevation of 10ft. above sea level, and a 25ft. wide dune dune at an elevation of 15ft. above sea level. The plan also includes the rehabilitation of the existing 16 groins and the construction of and additional 4.

Why was this plan created?
The ACOE has stated that this plan was devised to minimize potential damage to homeowners' property in the event of a storm (flooding from the bay side is not addressed). However, the effectiveness of such a plan to that end is questionable. There are no guarantees, and it cannot be proven that plans of this type work. In fact, there is evidence to suggest that sand replenishment has led to FASTER erosion in the Outer Banks of North Carolina.

What will the effects of the ACOE's plan be?
This plan will change the face of Long Beach. Instead of walking down the stairs from the boardwalk and immediately onto the beach, there will be "fingers" constructed to take you over the massive dune that has been proposed. The legendary sand that Long Beach is known for will be covered with dredged up ocean silt , and the sharp drop-off of the shore into the ocean will lead to increased danger for swimmers, surfers, and body boarders. The "rehabilitation" of the jetties will endanger the existing ecosystems that have sprung up over the years, which will also have a detrimental effect on sport fishing and clamming.

What are the costs?
The Corps have estimated that the total initial cost of this project will be $92,852,600 . The projected cost for Long Beach residents is $5,691,000, with further replenishment needed every 5 years over the course of 50 years at a cost of $114,168,600 ( 9 cycles @ $12,685,400). Providing that all costs will remain the same, even over a 50 year period, the complete cost of this project will be $207,021,200.

The ACOE's plan for our shore was created for the purpose of protecting homeowners' property, not to preserve the beach and its recreational use. Ask yourself this question, "Why do you love Long Beach?" and it's doubtful that you'll answer "because of the oceanfront homes". People love Long Beach because of the BEACH. The ACOE should come up with a suitable plan that not only seeks to protect homeowners' property but also to preserve the beach itself. Beach grass planting programs to help dunes grow (already successful in the West End of Long Beach), and under-boardwalk dune construction are just two concepts that the ACOE needs to investigate further. Thousands of people flock to Long Beach every summer from the surrounding areas to enjoy the beach, but will they still come when the beach is less appealing to use and its waves unsurfable?

The Long Beach City Council is in the process of planning a public hearing for the ACOE's planned replenishment project. Take note of the date when it's announced and please attend. SAVE LONG BEACH!

  Contact us
Contact Jeff Kupferman for more information on how you can help.
  Protect Long Beach!

Write the Long Beach City Council a letter and ask them to consider alternatives for the ACOE beach fill plan.

  Related letters

Letter to Long Beach Council & Manager
SRF's Coastal Engineer's Determination Letter

  Related documents

Printable Flyer for Community Posting
Report: Similar Project is a catastrophy at Coney Island
Beach Cross-Section Report
Long Island Surfability Report
Long Island Surfability Appendix
Comparison of Plans
Report: Budget Leaves New York Beaches Unprotected
The Beach Plan: Where Do We Stand?

  Related links

Army Corps of Engineers
City of Long Beach
Taxpayer.net
Article with Donald Cresitello, the ACOE Project Planner
NYS DOS Division of Coastal Resources
Sea, Inlet, and Bay Conditions for Long Island
Surfrider's State of the Beach 2003 Report: New York summary
Shoreline Protection Project Work Sessions
Long Beach Barrier Island Shore Protection Project Petition

  Photos

Dredging photos of Sandy Hook, NJ and East Rockaway, NY
 
   
Copyright 2006, Surfrider NYC Chapter of Surfrider Foundation. All Rights Reserved.